לולב = חיים
On Sukkos the Torah commands taking four species, among them “כַּפֹּ֣ת תְּמָרִ֔ים, branches of palm trees”; the palm branch is the lulav. The law is “היבש פסול, a dry one is invalid.” The Rosh, a medieval authority on halacha, says it counts as dry once “הלבין פניו כמת, it has turned white like a dead person,” and he brings proof from the Yerushalmi, the Jerusalem Talmud, which learns this from the verse “לֹ֣א הַ֭מֵּתִים יְהַֽלְלוּ־יָ֑הּ, the dead do not praise Hashem.” Our Gemara, the Babylonian Talmud, invalidates it for a different reason, that it lacks “הד"ר, hadar,” beauty, which would disqualify it even before it turns white. Still, the Rosh writes, the Yerushalmi “ראי' גדולה היא, is a great proof.”
Bnei Yissaschar, a chassidic work arranged by the months of the year, asks: our Talmud disagrees with the Yerushalmi, and the halacha follows our Talmud, especially when it is the stricter view. Why would the Rosh lean on the Yerushalmi? He answers that the Rosh aimed at the truth, because in fact both give one reason.
It is known that לולב equals חיים, “life,” and the lulav draws life from the Supernal Knowledge, a level of the divine mind. So once it has turned white like a dead person it is invalid, as the Yerushalmi says.
That is the same reason our Talmud requires hadar. It alludes to Hadar, the last of the eight kings of Edom listed in Bereishis 36, “וַיִּמְלֹ֤ךְ תַּחְתָּיו֙ הֲדַ֔ר, and Hadar reigned in his place,” the one king of whom the Torah does not say that he died. He stands for the repair of the death and breaking of the ancient kings, the first worlds in Kabbalah, which shattered, after which they remained alive and enduring. So the two Talmuds do not disagree.
Bnei Yissaschar: Chassidus on the months and festivals by Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov, 19th century.
What the seforim read in 68
- לולב = חייםBnei Yissaschar, Sefat Emet, Zera Kodesh
- חיים = חכםAvodat Yisrael, Degel Machaneh Ephraim, Shem MiShmuel
- ויבן = חייםBeit Aharon, Degel Machaneh Ephraim, Ohr LaShamayim
- חלל = חייםBnei Yissaschar, Ohr LaShamayim, Mikdash Melekh on Zohar
- חיים = אהי"ה הוי"ה אהי"הMikdash Melekh, RaMaZ Commentary on Zohar, Marit HaAyin on Sanhedrin, Chomat Anakh on Jeremiah
- כ"ל ח"י = חיי"םSefat Emet, Pri Etz Chaim
- סח = חייםMarit HaAyin on Pesachim, Igros Kodesh — Lubavitcher Rebbe
- בלול = חייםMarit HaAyin on Sanhedrin, Nachal Kedumim on Torah
- כחם = חייםTiferet Shlomo
- אבינה = חייםKisse Rahamim on Avot D'Rabbi Natan
- חיים = זונהKisse Rahamim on Avot D'Rabbi Natan
- לידידי = חייםChomat Anakh on Jeremiah
- בנוי = חייםChomat Anakh on Song of Songs
- אלול = חיים with the kollelNachal Eshkol on Song of Songs
- חיים = 68Likutei Halakhot, Ben Porat Yosef, Beit Aharon
- לולב = 68Machzor Vitry, Ohr Zarua, Shenei Luchot HaBerit
- כל חי = 68Kaf HaChayim on Shulchan Arukh, Orach Chayim, Sha'ar HaKavanot
In Tanach
- ובני
- בניו
- ובין
- הנביא
- חיים
- ויבן
- חכם
- איביהם
- חלל
- זונה
- בימיו
- בגלגל
- ובימי
- חטאים
- אזני
- אביהן
- בינו
- חילך
- בנוי
- אבניה
- בלול
- כחם
- בחחים
- ואכלהו
- ובכלי
- יחן
- ינהג
- לחכי
- לחל
- לידידי
- נביאה
- נדחו
- אבינה
- באהליך
- בבטנה
- האזנה
- הזנו
- ואבנט
- והמזבח
- ולכבוד
- יבנו
- ינוב
- כחיל
- מחיי
- מטיט
- סבו
- אזין
- באלהיך
- באניה
- בדיבן
- בהיכלא
- בוני
- ביון
- הבונה
- הגלל
- ואכלוה
- ואסא
- ובזזום
- ודחן
- והדגן
- והחמט
- וזנה
- וחמטה
- ויבדילו
- וכלהבה
- ולטוביה
- ונאוה
- ונודב
- זינא
- יגדליהו
- יכיחך
- כאהבם
- כלובי
- לבול
- לגיחזי
- לגלה
- להביאך
- מחטאי
- מכח
- נובי
First appearance of ובני
וּבְנֵ֖י גֹּ֑מֶר אַשְׁכְּנַ֥ז וְרִיפַ֖ת וְתֹגַרְמָֽה׃